A historic UES homestead built in 1863 hits the market for $13.9 million

Although New York is best known for its towering skyscrapers, this city has no shortage of historic homes. Built during the Civil War, this Victorian rowhouse is one of the oldest homes in New York City. The four-story townhouse is the only surviving piece of the original project, which included five matching homes and was completed in 1863. Now, it could be yours for $13.9 million.

This remarkable residence is located in the most coveted part of Lenox Hill, called “Millionaires’ Row”. It is also a part of the Upper East Side Historic District. The 4-bedroom, 5-bathroom townhouse spans more than 5,600 square feet. A decade ago, the owner restored the home’s red-brick façade to its original appearance with a new stoop and front doorway.

The 160-year-old Lenox Hill home has five wood-burning fireplaces and a front and back yard with lush plantings. Once you enter this townhouse, you will come across an impressive double-height conservatory that offers access to the lower levels and the backyard. The ground level also includes a home office, an eat-in kitchen, and a formal dining room. 

The dramatic staircase will lead you to the parlor floor. Here you will find a sophisticated living room with a piano and fireplace featuring an original wood-carved surround. There is also a separate library on this level with beautiful woodwork, floor-to-ceiling bookshelves and an abundance of natural light. This Upper East Side rowhouse is the perfect blend of historic details and modern living. 

The primary bedroom occupies the entire second floor. It has a ton of storage space, a walk-through en-suite bathroom, and a private study, which could be transformed into an additional bedroom. The remaining bedrooms take up the third floor. Both bedrooms come with their own bathroom. 

The building at 129 East 70th Street sits just three blocks from Central Park. It is also surrounded by a variety of dining and shopping options, as well as 6 and Q subway lines. The private outdoor space is a top must-have amenity that allows you to host social gatherings and relax after a long day at work. 

Resources:

“The Upper East Side historic district’s oldest home asks $13.9M,” by Michelle Cohen (6sqft, 2023)

“Restored: Oldest Surviving Building in the Upper East Side Historic District,” (News from Friends, 2010)

“The Charming 1863 No. 129 East 70th Street,” by Tom Miller (Daytonian in Manhattan, 2012)